Thursday, August 28th, 2003
Sometimes I wonder how an individual can just ooze ignorance so freely as a self-important “artiste.” I’ve been contacted in the past by rabid fans of bad bands. They’ve hurled half-assed death threats and the like. But in all honesty, I’ve never ever gotten contacted by the lead singer in a band.
Well, that all changed yesterday with the asshole-of-the-year John Speck (current of The Fags). I wrote a review a while back of his former band, Hoarse, and their only LP Happens Twice. It wasn’t a nice one, and it shouldn’t have been. The album is, was, and will always be horrid. Anyway, he took offense to my words. I guess that means that they are plenty powerful, and if nothing else that pleases me greatly.
First he admits the album sucks–of course not the fault of the band but rather the record company. Then he criticized me, testing my music knowledge and pulling out the big guns with his 25 years of guitar prowess. Yeah whatever. Then he questions my qualifications. Basically, he says that people that don’t play music don’t have the right to write about it. Finally, he threatens me…wanting to confront me in person at a show of his new band ‘The Fags.’ What a jerk.
I also sent this to my sister who quickly pointed out that many of the most famous music reviewers ever were incapable of playing so much as a tune on any instrument. She also pointed out that to appreciate and have an ear for music is a very different thing than to play it. And playing music doesn’t automatically mean that you are good at it. Same thing goes for writing it.
Oh, and her boyfriend Robin is a pretty seasoned music journalist in the UK and he said The Fags are a bad rip-off of the “The” band mini-genre. Go figure. Another carbon copy. Bad, bad, Mr. Speck. So without further ado, I present to you first the review that stirred up the controversy and then the letter itself.






